UK forced to admit secret order to weaken Apple encryption

A cracked padlock suspended between two identical smartphones, one glowing faintly behind a translucent shield, the other exposed to faint shadowy hands reaching from below, lit by a cold overhead bea

The UK government has been forced to acknowledge it issued a secret Technical Capability Notice (TCN) to Apple under the Investigatory Powers Act 2016, demanding changes to its encryption systems. The Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled on 17 September 2026 that the government could no longer maintain its policy of neither confirming nor denying the order’s existence, calling its secrecy claims insufficient to justify withholding the information.

A rare judicial check on surveillance secrecy

The tribunal’s decision marks a significant, if narrow, victory for transparency. While it does not rule on the legality of the order itself, it rejects the Home Office’s argument that disclosing the notice would harm national security. The ruling follows a legal challenge brought by civil rights organisations Liberty and Privacy International, who argued that the government’s refusal to confirm widely reported facts undermined public trust and obstructed judicial scrutiny. Ben Jaffey KC likened the secrecy to the “emperor’s new clothes,” asserting it brought the justice system into disrepute.

How Apple responded to the demand

In February 2025, after the Washington Post revealed the initial order, Apple chose not to comply by building a backdoor. Instead, it withdrew its Advanced Data Protection (ADP) feature for new UK users. ADP extends end-to-end encryption to more categories of iCloud data — such as photos, notes, and backups — meaning even Apple cannot access them. Existing UK users who had already enabled ADP were not forced to disable it, creating a two-tier security model: users like ‘Alice’, who activated ADP before February 2025, retain full protection, while ‘Bill’, a new user, cannot enable it at all.

Global implications and diplomatic fallout

The original January 2025 notice reportedly sought access to encrypted iCloud data worldwide, triggering diplomatic concern in the US. Officials from the Trump administration and US lawmakers objected, warning it could set a precedent endangering American users’ privacy. In response, the UK narrowed the order to apply only to British users. Apple, still barred from discussing the notice publicly, launched a fresh legal challenge in 2026 after the second TCN was issued. The company reiterated its stance: it has never built, and will never build, a backdoor or master key into its products.

What it means

This case reveals a growing tension between state surveillance powers and global tech platforms. The UK’s use of secret orders under the Investigatory Powers Act creates opacity not just for the public, but for users whose data protections vary based on timing and jurisdiction. For businesses, especially those relying on cloud services, this highlights a risk: encryption guarantees may be undermined by jurisdiction-specific legal demands. The lack of disclosure obligations for companies receiving TCNs means users cannot know whether their provider has been compelled to weaken security.

For UK-based founders and IT leaders, the takeaway is clear: data control is increasingly contingent on national laws, not just technical architecture. In the UAE and Kazakhstan, where data sovereignty laws are tightening, similar models could emerge. The US remains a key battleground, as any cross-border data access demand risks friction with US privacy norms and legislation like the CLOUD Act.

A step toward accountability, not resolution

The tribunal’s decision does not disclose the technical requirements of the notice or determine whether the UK has the legal authority to compel Apple to change its encryption. A final hearing on what further details can be made public is expected in 2027. Apple welcomes the transparency, but the core conflict remains unresolved. As governments demand access in the name of public safety, and companies resist to protect user trust, the balance between security and privacy continues to shift — often in the shadows. Today’s ruling shines a small light, but much remains hidden.

Sources

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *